Why is accurate – or authentic – Masonic research so important?
The importance of making a daily advancement in Masonic knowledge is something that The Square is passionate about promoting.
Most days we send out messages on social media containing thought-provoking and useful quotes, suggestions, or questions.
But key to Masonic knowledge is the information we receive and the accuracy of that information, whether it be in a book, journal or magazine, on a website, or social media.
There is an abundance of material that has been written about Freemasonry since its official beginnings in the early eighteenth century, much of which has come from official publications via Grand Lodges, or authentic papers and transactions written by scholars associated with Masonic Research Lodges.
However, there is equally as much written that is at the least inaccurate, and at worst, inflammatory and dangerous.
As a reader, unless you are a seasoned researcher, you will probably not be able to tell if something is inaccurate or not.
Misinformation occurs for many reasons: have you ever played ‘telephone’ or ‘Chinese whispers‘? These games allude to how a quote or piece of information has passed through so many people that the original message has been irretrievably lost or altered.
There is a humorous anecdote regarding a message sent during wartime that began as: ‘Send reinforcements, we’re going to advance’ and at the end of the relayed transmission became ‘send three and fourpence, we’re going to a dance’.
This is an example not only of how relayed stories or quotes can become completely distorted but also the fact that the anecdote itself has been reported in several different versions, and contexts, since 1915!
Another reason for inaccuracies can be anything from simple typos, fanciful speculation and/or dubious interpretations surrounding almost every aspect of Freemasonry (usually perpetuated by non-Masons).
You only have to view some of the more out-there websites and forums to see examples of some seriously fanciful notions about Freemasonry and Masons in general.
Think about how this kind of misinformation has impacted the Organisation, do you want to perpetuate any of it, even if some of it looks historically or factually accurate to you?
But misinformation can also come from those within the Fraternity – perhaps their research was not thorough enough, and they merely repeated someone else’s inaccurate research; or illogical conclusions had been drawn, or confirmation bias involved.
Confirmation bias is something we all do to some extent but some writers – especially of the more esoteric branches of Freemasonry – succumb to it on a regular basis, often distorting things to a ludicrous level.
These ‘facts’ are often then embedded in more and more publications or platforms and we have to unpick their ‘facts’ to get to the actual truth of the matter.
Just because we want something to be true, doesn’t mean it is.
Confirmation bias – the tendency to search for, interpret, favour, and recall information that confirms or supports one’s prior personal beliefs or values.
The English philosopher and scientist Francis Bacon (1561–1626) wrote about confirmation bias in his Novum Organum [New Organon(1620)] he wrote that biased assessment of evidence drove ‘all superstitions, whether in astrology, dreams, omens, divine judgments or the like’. He followed with the observation that:
The human understanding when it has once adopted an opinion…draws all things else to support and agree with it. And though there be a greater number and weight of instances to be found on the other side, yet these it either neglects or despises, or else by some distinction sets aside or rejects[.]
Academics and lay-researchers of all disciplines have to learn how to conduct research without bias and it’s not easy.
So, how can we tell that the information we have discovered is authentic?
IMAGE CREDIT: by John Hain from Pixabay
Firstly, we must develop critical thinking
(there is an in-depth feature about this on page 26)
the objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgement.
What does a critical thinker do when evaluating information?
They ‘analyse, evaluate, explain, and restructure thinking, thereby ensuring the act of thinking without false belief’.
The research must be ‘authentic’.
According to the Social Research Glossary, ‘Authentic’ is defined as:
‘something that is genuine or that represents the essence of an idea…something that is the real article or something that is genuine rather than being a reproduction, copy or something masquerading as something that it is not. This applies, for example, to historical objects: are they really from when they purport to be or are they later copies. This might apply to non-tangible objects such as music or poetry as well as more tangible cultural objects such as pottery, paintings and so on.’
[Harvey, L., 2012-20, Social Research Glossary, Quality Research International]
A good researcher:
- asks pertinent questions
- looks for evidence to support claims
- assesses statements and arguments without bias
- suspends own judgements/beliefs until backed up by critical examination
- is not afraid to accept information that does not align with preconceived beliefs or ideas (confirmation bias)
- is humble enough to admit any lack of understanding and is willing to learn
- clearly defines a set of criteria for analysis
- can give and receive critical feedback
- rejects information that is incorrect or irrelevant
- cross-references and then cross-references again – dates, names, facts
- uses plagiarism/fact and quote checkers
How do we trust an author’s information or version of events? Not all authors are automatically experts.
We should ask:
- What credentials does the author have?
- What have they written previously and where was it published?
- What background in the subject does he/she have?
- His/her reputation in Masonic circles?
- Peer reviews
- Is there anything the author is trying to prove – are they obviously biased towards one aspect of a subject and not entertaining another?
- Is the work adequately referenced, what are their sources?
- Is the information up-to-date?
The subject of how to research – and write – is a huge one; this article is merely a short introduction.
But it is a subject we will be covering over the forthcoming issues, and The Square will be offering an exclusive course for aspiring Masonic authors and researchers. Watch this space!
You may have noticed that The Square often hyperlinks to external sources, including Wikipedia (which has its own issues). Why do we link to Wikipedia? Even though some of the information may not be 100% accurate, it is, on the whole, a reasonably reliable source of quick information for those seeking a definition or an introduction to a subject. We would not recommend it as an end resource for research, but it is a fantastic stepping stone for the curious mind!
Check those quotes, did Socrates really say that?! https://quoteinvestigator.com/
Have you read that somewhere before? Put the page through a plagiarism checker: https://www.grammarly.com/plagiarism-checker
A Research lodge is a particular type of Masonic lodge which is devoted to Masonic research.
It is a lodge, and as such has a charter from some Grand Lodge. However, it does not confer degrees, and restricts membership to Master Masons of some jurisdiction in amity with the jurisdiction that the Research Lodge is in.
Related to Research Lodges are Masonic research societies, which serve the same purpose but function fundamentally differently.
There are research lodges in most countries where Freemasonry exists.
The oldest Research Lodge is Quatuor Coronati No. 2076, founded in 1886 under the jurisdiction of the United Grand Lodge of England.
It accepts members from all over the world through its Correspondence Circle. A book of transactions called Ars Quatuor Coronatorum (which includes the papers given in the lodge) has been published every year since 1886.
Most Research Lodges have some type of transactions, proceedings, or even just a newsletter that is published regularly.
There is a comprehensive, but not exhaustive list, of worldwide research Lodges here:
Article by: Philippa Lee. Editor
Philippa Lee (writes as Philippa Faulks) is the author of eight books, an editor and researcher.
Philippa was initiated into the Honourable Fraternity of Ancient Freemasons (HFAF) in 2014.
Her specialism is ancient Egypt, Freemasonry, comparative religions and social history. She has several books in progress on the subject of ancient and modern Egypt. Selection of Books Online at Amazon
How To Research (Open Up Study Skills)
by Loraine Blaxter; Christina Hughes;
How to Research is a clear and accessible guide to the business of doing a research project. It systematically takes the reader through from the planning to the writing up and finishing off. The new edition of this book will include:
-Expanded section on methodology
-Expanded section on Literature Reviews
-Inclusion of a glossary
(Mla Handbook for Writers of Research Papers)
by Modern Language Association
The Modern Language Association, the authority on research and writing, takes a fresh look at documenting sources in the eighth edition of the MLA Handbook.
Works are published today in a dizzying range of formats. A book, for example, may be read in print, online, or as an e-book–or perhaps listened to in an audio version.
On the Web, modes of publication are regularly invented, combined, and modified. Previous editions of the MLA Handbookprovided separate instructions for each format, and additional instructions were required for new formats.
In this groundbreaking new edition of its best-selling handbook, the MLA recommends instead one universal set of guidelines, which writers can apply to any type of source.
Shorter and redesigned for easy use, the eighth edition of the MLA Handbook guides writers through the principles behind evaluating sources for their research.
It then shows them how to cite sources in their writing and create useful entries for the works-cited list.
More than just a new edition, this is a new MLA style.
Research Papers For Dummies
by Geraldine Woods
You’re sitting at your desk in a classroom or in an airless cubicle, wondering how many minutes are left in a seemingly endless day, when suddenly your teacher or supervisor lowers the boom:
She wants a research paper, complete with footnotes and a list of sources. She wants accuracy, originality, and good grammar. And – gasp! – she wants ten pages! You may be 16 years old or 60 years old, but your reaction is the same: Help!
Take heart. A research paper may seem daunting, but it’s a far-from-impossible project to accomplish. Turning research into writing is actually quite easy, as long as you follow a few proven techniques.
And that’s where Research Papers For Dummies steps in to help. In this easy-to-understand guide, you find out how to search for information using both traditional printed sources and the electronic treasure troves of the Internet.
You also discover how to take all those bits of information, discarding the irrelevant ones, and put them into a form that illustrates your point with clarity and originality.
Recent Articles: history series
The Ritual of the Operative Free Masons - P3
Existing Operative Free Masons. The ritual I am about to refer, is that of "The Worshipful Society of Free Masons, Rough Masons, Wallers, Slaters, Paviors, Plaisterers, and Bricklayers." By Thomas Carr, M.D., P. M. Honorary Member of the Guild of Operative Free Masons
The Ritual of the Operative Free Masons - P2
If anyone doubts the fact that the formation of Speculative Free Masonry was due to and based upon Operative Free Masonry, it is quite easy to convince him of his error if he will only study the first Book of Constitutions. By Thomas Carr, M.D., P. M. Honorary Member of the Guild of Operative Free Masons
The Ritual of the Operative Free Masons - P1
The original paper was written, first, to prove that Speculative Free Masonry was derived from Operative Free Masonry; second, to give some account of the Operative Free Masons, of their Ritual, and of their customs. By Thomas Carr, M.D., P. M. Honorary Member of the Guild of Operative Free Masons
The Perjured Free Mason Detected
Was Samuel Prichard a perjured individual, or simply a misguided Freemason? Prichard's book "Free Masonry Dissected" published in 1730, is now used by many Masonic historians as a source of reference with regards to the introduction of the third degree into the Craft. But at the time it was published in 1730, it was not so well received by members of the Grand Lodge of England.
The Order of the Dragon
Societas Draconistarum, meaning "Society of the Dragonists"– was a chivalric Order for selected nobility, founded in 1408 by Sigismund von Luxembourg, who through marriage became the King of Hungary (1387–1437) and later Holy Roman Emperor. The Order was fashioned after the military orders of the Crusades, requiring its initiates to defend the cross and fight the enemies of Christianity, in particular the Ottoman Empire.
17th century and the Holy Royal Arch
This article focuses on a period of transition between a point in time when we can safely and historically identify the first formation of what could be called as the ‘Royal Arch’ and the historical events that have preceded it.
Most Freemasons have heard the terms 'Operative' and 'Speculative' Masons, and this article helps to understand the difference:
Roberts' Constitutions of Freemasonry 1722
Published a year before Anderson's Constitutions, The Old Constitutions Belonging to the Ancient and Honourable SOCIETY OF Free and Accepted MASONS. Originally printed in London England; Sold by J. Roberts, in Warwick-Lane, MDCCXXII.(1722)
A Song of Freemasonry
From 'Songs of religion and life', 1876 by John Stuart Blackie (1809-1895)
On the Antiquity of Masonic Symbolism
Is the Symbolism of Masonry an inheritance derived from the old Masons who flourished before the era of the Grand Lodges (1717); or has it been borrowed from the Rosicrucians or others, after 1717?
Mason's Marks – from Egypt to Europe?
Mason's marks have been a source of intrigue, not only to Freemasons but to historians and archaeologists. The use of simple pictograms have been employed for millennia by artisans to identify their work. But where did they originate and why?
The White House Foundation Stones
Further to the articles in our series on the history of the stone masons, we have a rather intriguing addition. During the 1950's renovation of the White House, President Truman retrieved more than 100 stone blocks with stonemasons marks.
The Green Dragon Tavern
What the Goose and Gridiron Tavern is in the ancient annals of London Freemasonry, The Green Dragon Tavern is to the memories of the Free-mason, of Boston and New England.
when hate goes too far
Auschwitz concentration camp: video photo article taken in 2013
Martin Bogardus explores the Masonic characters and symbolism within the hugely successful 'Outlander' books and TV series.
27 January 1945
There are two things of importance happening this day - 27 January
Understanding of Freemasonry
Two approaches regarding the understanding of Freemasonry
Masonic Research in England c1930
An article which appeared in an American Masonic magazine, c1930 and which was reproduced in England, provoking a little controversy.
A 1657 Masonic? Bookplate
Masonic bookplates the ‘Brethren’s spiritual coats of arms and marks’
The Unlawful Societies Act of 1799
Rebellious Freemasons and the 21st century
The Lost Jewel
In 1912, Sarah Dowd of Dromore, Ireland, found a Masonic jewel dated 1517 - a date two hundred years before the establishment of Grand Lodge...
Benjamin Franklin’s Virtues
Benjamin Franklin's Virtues, Freemasonry, and Jewish Practice.
Franklin's Virtues Revisited For Today's Mason
How are the virtues and the pursuit of self-improvement and knowledge as pertinent for today's Mason, as they were for Benjamin Franklin.
Origins and Links to English Freemasonry - Part 3
Quasi-Masonic societies - are the highly secretive Skull and Bones the real Illuminati?
Origins and Links to English Freemasonry - Part 2
The Regius MS & Deciphering the Oldest Charges
Origins and Links to English Freemasonry - Part 1
Unexpected links between the Freemasonry of today with the original Operative builders.
Freemasonry and Fascist Regime
Interesting speech by the famous historian Prof. Aldo A. Mola, who links the fascist regime with the Masonic Associations.
Ovid 25 Lodge
Was famous Russian poet Alexander Pushkin a Freemason? And if so, was he a member of the lodge ‘for which all the lodges in Russia were destroyed’?
The Importance of Masonic Research
An introduction to Masonic research - how to know what is authentic...and what is not!
The Antient Noble Order of the Gormogons had a brief existence in the eighteenth century; they left few records or accomplishments, and there is no indication as to their true purpose other than to parody and degrade Freemasonry, and perhaps further the Jacobite cause.
Four Times of the Day - Night
Hogarth's mockery of Freemasonry. A humorous depictions of life in the streets of London, the vagaries of fashion, and the interactions between the rich and poor.
Russian Freemasonry a combination of a short sketch of its history and a review of the present-day Masonic landscape in this country
to be a better citizen of the world
share the square with two brothers
click image to open email app on mobile device